Well, its confirmed. Shadow Hall is not that effective.
Shadow Hall Effectiveness
On May 5, 2025 at 18:59:23:
My Lord, my Lord, we were invaded by Heaven at Lithar-7! Enemies are upon us. They took everything what they could, our troops were unable to defend our kingdom. We must do something now!
We lost 1 Castle(s) sorrounded by 33 lands.
In this lands are also constructed : 68 Advanced Training Center , 0 Farm , 18 Forge , 34 Guard House , 0 Guard Tower , 22 House , 6 Market , 1 Medical Center , 0 Mill , 0 Mine , 20 School , 34 Training Center ,
We managed to kill : 0 Knight 3 Infantry 2 Pikeman 4 Heavy Infantry 0 Archer 4 Mounted Archers
But we lost : 0 Mage 2 Swordman 1 Lanceman 0 Caragous 2 Archer 0 Elite Archer
On May 5, 2025 at 18:47:18:
My Lord, my Lord, we were invaded by Gnomeville at Lithar-1! Enemies are upon us. They took everything what they could, our troops were unable to defend our kingdom. We must do something now!
We lost 1 Castle(s) sorrounded by 34 lands.
In this lands are also constructed : 68 Advanced Training Center , 0 Farm , 18 Forge , 33 Guard House , 0 Guard Tower , 21 House , 6 Market , 1 Medical Center , 0 Mill , 0 Mine , 20 School , 34 Training Center ,
We managed to kill : 15 Catapult 35 Infantry 392 Militia 21 Rider 468 Rock thrower 9 Balista
But we lost : 0 Mage 364 Swordman 242 Lanceman 0 Caragous 346 Archer 0 Elite Archer
On May 5, 2025 at 18:41:58:
Oh mighty xiAo-Shin Star, ruler of the once-great Bayang City, how the mighty have fallen! �
Your grand "attack" on Heaven was less a battle and more a parade of incompetence—led by none other than you, the legendary Lord Eagle's personal cheerleader! 
Your troops now flee in shame, your "strategy" is the stuff of tavern jokes, and your kingdom's pride? Crushed like a grape under the boot of reality. 
Better luck next time... if there is a next time. 
We managed to kill : 13 Knight 0 Infantry 0 Pikeman 0 Heavy Infantry 0 Archer 0 Mounted Archers
But we lost : 621 Mage 595 Swordman 342 Lanceman 454 Caragous 732 Archer 763 Elite Archer
WHERE'S MY SHADOW HALL?
xiAo-Shin Star 2 attacks isn't a really good sample size, you could have just rolled badly on both attacks. Plus one was a retal, I wonder if retals circumvent shadow hall 
Lord Thane
Shadow hall been up always, All attacks has been successful none got fog by the Shadow hall.
I've add this to the bug board.
How was it guys? Did the Shadow hall worked on you?
xiAo-Shin Star Thekeeper tested it and found it was functioning as expected. Perhaps some bad luck for you.
- Edited
Hell noooooo... This can't be!!! Where my luck go? Did you took it huh?
TheKeeper cast it on me yesterday, it was annoying because when I tried to do test attacks last night the shadow hall was still active... It took 7 attacks to make 1 attack, first 6 went into fog
I also had it casted on me lol that was fun, didn’t know it could go on others but honestly I like that idea… if maybe only within province would give elves a bit more gusto if they could SH the whole team!
- Edited
On May 6, 2025 at 03:16:58:
Lo! I, the shadowed sovereign of Thardferr, have plundered the eldritch arcana of the Elves, wrested from their starlit sanctums beneath the Eternal Grove! With guile and grit, I breached their hallowed wards, seizing the primal essence of their magic to share its radiant might with thee, brave souls of the realm. From the blackened spires of my cursed keep, wreathed in mists of sorrow and defiance, I have hurled myself into the aether, a beacon of stolen starfire to light the path for all who dare wield the forbidden! Arise, and taste the legacy of the ancients!
The Keeper successfully cast a Shadow Hall spell, Your kingdom will be hidden from your enemies for 12 days
On May 6, 2025 at 17:55:43:
Your forces have lost their way reaching to BoD in what appears to be a thick, magical fog. It will be 3 game days before they will be able to find their way home.
Your forces have lost their way in what appears to be a thick, magical fog. It will be 3 game days before they will be able to find their way home.
Shadow Hall working in the opposite way or maybe both ways. Kingdom with Shadow Hall shouldn't get lost on the way. Also, if i remember correctly a kingdom with shadow hall was not listed under the province list (only in the dropdown menu of attacks/spells/messages etc.)
- Edited
Hmm, so it is not working both ways. Thanks for the heads-up, didn't see that while fast reading and scrolling.
@MithicYort
A suggestion about Shadow Hall hiding: as i mentioned above in old Thardferr the kingdom under shadow hall was not listed in the province (where you reach via the Kingdom link). If this is going to be implemented, i suggest to remove from KHoF as well. It is a very expensive spell to cast and not being listed in KHoF provides an advantage to avoid random attacks or being KHoF watched especially in a crowded playerbase.
Leo you want kingdoms under shadow hall to hide from HoF and province? That seems excessive
Yes, lol. It is a very expensive spell to cast. Still won't be worth it but at least.
Btw, do you confirm that shadow hall used to remove the caster from the province list? I am not certain of my memory.
I don’t hate the KHoF not posted at all times, maybe if a snapshot is uploaded once per day. That would give advantage to players who are tracking however if you attacked at the first tick after the update your army would already be home when the next update occurred so maybe there is some validity to it… or it only publishes your average KS through the last 24hours not sure how easy that would be to implement… but could be a nice feature.
I repeat Shadow Hall is not working! lol.
My KD's Shadow Hall is not working lmao.