Bug Reports on GitHub, Please!

DougEfresh

Lord Thane should change quick retreat to that

Lord Thane

DougEfresh I like that idea, we could tweak quick retreat to do that.

Or maybe it should just be a new feature that works all the time, so people stop getting zeroed out. Need to put that to vote.

Mack10

Attacker Totals
Melee Attack Power: 33,635
Ranged Attack Power: 37,395
Total Offensive Output: 71,030
Total Defense: 78,700

Cats - 1838 = 27570*2 For Far fighting (With explosive, didnt add that in cuz i dont know what it is) Range
Inf - 3874 = 19370
Mil - 13033 = 52132
Rider - 5835 = 52515
RT - 26441 = 39661 *2 For far fighting 79322
Bal - 3086 = 30860 *2 for far fighting 61720
Offensive power 196 182 Ranged Alone

Is this divided? And if so How does a Human out range a gnome? with 12k archers?
I am not following your math?

Defender had
5k knights, = 65000
6k heavy infantry, = 60000
6k archers, = 42000
6k mount archers. = 66000
1k pikes = 7000
240,000 Defence
36000 Long Range Damage*2 for FF so 72000 Ranged offensive

I dont want to beat a dead horse, but how can an army full of units, you could never support without this type of resources only kill <1% of another army?
I have never in my 20 years of playing this seen a Battle report with so many units involved and <1% dies?
You make it seem like I fucked up but I dont see how its mathematically possible?
Especially with so much that came home (I can maybe credit some of that to 2:1 MC's)

CyberPtra

5k knights, 6k heavy infantry, 6k archers, 6k mount archers. And 1k pikes.

These are approximate numbers taking first digit of the unit (rounded down). So “5k” could be 5000-5999, etc. The pike is the only unit that was exactly 1k. If you want to figure the math, consider adding 500 to each unit (except pike) to get the “average”. Nevertheless, I was curious by the attack/defend as well.

At the time:
No Strat
2:1 MC
Bow tech
Sword tech
Knight healing
BAS 5

Mack10

I should Add
2:1 MC's on attack
BAS 5ish as well
Sling Tech
3/3 SB
Explosive powder
Far Fighting

Xliest

Mack10 why you hef to be mad, it’s just a game.

Mack10

Xliest
I am upset yes, I wanted to know why I lost, I am given numbers that dont add up and told I sent a weak force against an overwhelmingly strong one when I was in 2nd place. I had a gigantic army that took a week to build and I killed 178 units and kept getting ignored why this happened.
I ask others and everyone else that has looked at the numbers said something isnt right as well.

Why are you jumping into this conversation without anything productive to add? To stir the shit pot?

Lord Thane

Mack10 my analysis was based on the data you gave, the battle report, so I assumed that was a zeroed out army on your part. The new data about what you sent would have altered it, as would all the modifiers that weren't counted as well. Unfortunately I don't think anyone has time to look into it any further. Onward and upward we go to the next rounds of testing.

That's what the beta is about too, testing. That's why everyone got resources, and we tweaked tech times. We looked at 100 battle reports and ran polls and had dozens of discussions, now we're moving on to implementing changes. Spending more time on a 101th report isn't going to get us anywhere, we need to focus on getting actual changes in place so we can see if things improved.

Mack10

Lord Thane Fair enough.
Just getting my last word in, this was by far the worst BR of everything I have seen, I know you dont want to dig anymore into it but this is what 'testing' is all about, finding the worst bugs and correcting them. I felt this was something that really needed attention as something went really wrong and it just seemed like it needed addressing. You and Keeper do not feel the same way so I will drop the subject and move on.

Xliest

Mack10 you understand that this is a test, right? A first test at that, you should be happy you found a big that can be fixed!

Mack10

Xliest Would of been nice to apart of the big battles though.
Now I just get picked apart by vultures.

I am glad we found the bug at least but again, did you need to come in to stir the shitpot?
What is your KD by the way? You seem to have a different Forum name then KD name?

Xliest

Mack10 I do have different forum and KD name this is intentional. I do post often to stir, however when people come in soo hot at issue's, like you have been it’s really easy fodder.

Lord Thane

Mack10 I added an extra digit on all your troops, now you can go have a big battle with the latest formula in place 💪

Jets

Lord Thane may I have some more sir

saadht

@Lord Thane please check the GitHub, there's a massive army disappearance bug.

Lord Thane

saadht I think I found the bug you experienced, I will update the castle thread with my fix and recap of it in a moment.

Lord Thane

Jets yes I think I hooked you up with a decent troop dump, did you want more than that? You're gonna make someone hate me for this lol

Jets

Lord Thane we are here to test the game right? I'm doing my part for science and drama.

MithicYort

Oh this is where the extra 300k KS came from!? I thought this was a bug!

saadht

Oh my. You're lucky I don't hold grudges anymore, @Lord Thane . Lol.

« Previous Page Next Page »